RATBOTS
USING RATS AS ROBOTS
Abstract :
“Robot" as an "apparently human automation, intelligent but impersonal machine..."
A
ratbot or roborat is a rat controlled through implants in
its brain.
Guided rats controlled through
implants in their brains could one day be used to search for landmines or
buried victims of earthquakes, scientists say.
An extraordinary experiment has seen researchers steering five rodents - so-called rat bots - through an obstacle course by remote control.
Writing in the journal Nature, the scientists say the ratbots could reach places inaccessible to humans or machines.
An extraordinary experiment has seen researchers steering five rodents - so-called rat bots - through an obstacle course by remote control.
Writing in the journal Nature, the scientists say the ratbots could reach places inaccessible to humans or machines.
"One can think of the guided
rat as a very good robot platform capable of traversing terrain that modern
robots are unable to do," Dr Talwar said
The rodents in the first experiment wore a small electronics backpack that linked to electrodes in their brains. They received radio commands from a laptop that would stimulate sensations in their whiskers and reward/pleasure receptors to manipulate them into following pre-programmed routes. Some researchers propose using them to search for landmines or buried victims of earthquakes, as they can much more efficiently scout such areas than human rescuers or existing robots.
The rats also quickly learnt to
associate the stimulation of their brains' reward centres with simply walking
forwards, even if this involved climbing or descending ladders or steps, or
moving into the centre of a brightly lit room - something that most rats would
avoid.
INTRODUCTION
Rat - common name for any large
member of a family of rodents, with dull - colored, coarse fur; long tails;
large ears; and a pointed snout. Rats have extremely powerful teeth, with which
they often gnaw through wooden planks to get at stores of food, and they have
even been known to bite holes in lead pipes. They are usually nocturnal and
live in human habitations, in forests, in deserts, and on seagoing ships. They
are extremely prolific, breeding 1 to 13 times a year and producing 1 to 22
young in a litter. Most species of rats are herbivorous, but some are
omnivorous. Rats have an average lifespan of eight months to one year in the
wild and two to three years in captivity.
·
Animals have often been used by humans
in combat and in search and rescue, but not under direct computer-to-brain
electronic control.
·
The advent of surgically altered
roborats marks the crossing new boundary in the mechanization, and potential
militarization, of nature.
·
This ratbot technology isn’t
nanotechnology yet, and it is not new, as the principle of “MIND CONTROL”
through implantable devices is the same
THE
FIRST ROBORAT
"Robo-rat"
controlled by brain electrodes
The age of the living robot is upon us. And all it takes
to turn a living rat into a radio-controlled automaton is three electrodes
carefully placed in the animal's brain. Simply pressing keys on a computer 500
meters away will then steer the animal over an obstacle course, making it
twist, turn and even jump on demand.
The researchers responsible for the
"Robo Rat" claim their work will give neuroscientists a better
understanding of how mammals learn to navigate. They say it will help pinpoint biochemical
changes in the brain, and which brain regions are involved in processing
different behaviours. They even suggest that such rats could be used to help
clear minefields.
But beyond this, lead researcher
Sanjiv Talwar of the State University of New York in New York City is uncertain
what benefits will emerge from the experiments. "It's difficult to predict
what other studies this could be useful for right now," he told New
Scientist. "There's going to have to be a wide debate to see whether this
is acceptable or not."
The idea of placing living creatures
under direct human command is certainly raising concerns over the animals'
welfare. "It's appalling, and yet another example of how the human species
instrumentalises other species," says Gill Langley of the Dr Hadwen Trust
based in Hitchin, Hertfordshire, which funds alternatives to animal-based
research.
Brain electrodes
Animal experiments such as drug trials are usually
justified using the utilitarian argument. For a procedure to be acceptable, any
suffering caused to an animal is supposed to be outweighed by an obvious
benefit to people.
"There are some ethical issues
here which I can't deny," Talwar says. But he points out that the
experiments stuck to guidelines laid down by the US National Institutes of
Health, and he insists that the animal cannot be dubbed a
"remote-controlled rat". The rat was not forced to do anything, he
says, as the technique works by stimulating the reward centre of its brain.
The researchers implanted one of the
electrodes into the medial forebrain bundle (MFB), the part of the brain
responsible for sensing reward. They placed the other two in parts of the
somatosensory cortical area that receive stimulation from the left and right
whiskers. Finally, a radio receiver tucked inside a rat-sized backpack was
plugged into an interface in the rat's skull.
The rats were trained to learn that
they would be rewarded with continuous zaps to the MFB when they moved
forwards, or when they turned according to an appropriate stimulation of the
left or right whisker.
Carrot and stick
Talwar likens the control over the rat to the way a
donkey can be steered by a carrot on a stick. Though driven by a desire to be
rewarded, the donkey remains in control of its movements. Using the same
principle, the rat can be trained to do things it would not normally do, such
as walking into brightly lit open spaces or jumping off a ledge.
But Gary Francione, an expert in
animal welfare law at Rutgers University School of Law, says: "The animal
is no longer functioning as an animal," as the rat is operating under
someone's control.
And the issue goes beyond whether or
not the stimulations are compelling or rewarding the rat to act. "There's
got to be a level of discomfort in implanting these electrodes," he says,
which may be difficult to justify.
Talwar says the animals probably
could not be persuaded to risk their lives in any way. Even so, he admits he
cannot rule out coercion completely. For instance, the rats were never trained
to jump off a ledge, but would do when commanded to go forward.
In this case the stimulation
appeared to act like a prod rather than a reward. Previous research has shown
that if rats are stimulated electrically in this reward centre every time they
press a lever, they may continue doing so until they die.
Fast forward
Talwar has so far wired up five rats. He suggests that
other electrodes could be added to give additional commands, like faster, or up
and down. In theory, the technique should work with any animal that has an MFB,
including most mammals and birds, although it's likely that higher animals
could learn to ignore the commands.
Talwar suggests wired animals would
be ideal for search and rescue operations, as they could be directed through
rubble to look for survivors and would be easier to navigate than mechanical
robots.
But Langley is concerned that other
scientists will repeat the experiments on other animals, despite the ethical
issues this raises. "The US Federal Animal Welfare Act doesn't cover
rodents or birds," she points out, so researchers would not need a license
or ethical approval.
Journal
reference: Nature (vol 417, p 37)
Duncan
Graham-Rowe
INTO THE TOPIC
·
Two electrodes lead to the parts of the
rats' brains, which normally detect an obstacle against their whiskers. A third
plunges into an area of the brain identified as far back as the 1950s as
providing the rat with a feeling of pleasure when stimulated this area of
stimulation is called Medial Forebrain Bundle (MFB)
·
Once trained they would move
instantaneously and accurately as directed, for up to an hour at a time. The
rats could be steered up ladders, along narrow ledges and down ramps, up trees,
and into collapsed piles of concrete rubble.
STEP WISE PROCEDURE OF HOW RATBOTS ARE
BUILT
·
Step-1
After
anesthesia being given, the mouth of the rat is first cut in order
to go through the incision towards Brain.
·
Step-2
Now
the incision continues towards to the head position to reach the
brain
·
Step-3
The
Three electrodes used for stimulation are placed .
·
Step-4
A
Back Pack with batteries, an antenna, a receiver and a camera is placed
to rat as shown beside
·
Step-5
Finally the rat is
molded into Ratbot and the only thing left with
it is, it should be trained
HOW
RATBOTS LOOK LIKE…
The
remote control rats look like school children, wearing small backpacks that
house microprocessor-based remote-controlled stimulators. Wires connect the
backpack to tiny probes that have been placed into areas of the rat’s brain
that are responsible for reward and areas that process signals from their
whiskers. Manipulating these two areas of the brain controls the rats.
WORKING
(OR) OPERATION OF RATBOT
SCIENTISTS
OPINIONS (ABOUT RATBOT)
·
It could save a lot of lives. It's not
all bad for the rats because they feel pleasure when they go the right way
-------Sophie
·
Rats are small and can fit into places
where we can’t. If it helps save lives then we should implement it.
-------Ashley
APPLICATIONS
Ø Giant
Rats Trained To Sniff Out Land Mines
Ø Roborat
Could Help Find Earthquake Victims
Ø Used
to find explosives.
THE FUTURE
This
discovery grew out of ongoing research into the development of
thought-controlled prosthetic devices, roboroach, moving a cursor
using brain signal etc.,
EVOLUTION OF THE IDEA
The
work on guided rats was an offshoot of earlier research which showed that
animals wired up to a processor could command a robotic arm by thought alone, a
development which could potentially empower paralyzed humans
FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS
In one sense, the news
last week that scientists have created a "roborat" represents an
ingenious technical breakthrough. Engineers have tried for years--without
success--to build robots smart enough to cross even a railroad track. Now, by
combining off-the-shelf technology with a creature whose maneuvering skills
have been honed by millions of years of evolution, physiologists at the State
University of New York Downstate Medical Center in Brooklyn have created remotely
piloted rodents that navigate complex terrain at the will of controllers who
are more than 500 yards away. Wearing tiny backpacks equipped with radio
transmitters and miniature TV cameras, the rats could someday be sent into a
collapsed building to find survivors, say the scientists, or into a minefield
to sniff out danger or off on a spy mission.
But
look a little deeper, and the accomplishment is both less and more than meets
the eye. It's less in part because the technology involved is so simple.
Trainers have known for centuries that you can teach animals to perform all
sorts of behaviors with a system of rewards or punishments. Neurophysiologists
have known for decades that instead of an external reward like food, you can
send electric impulses directly into the brain's pleasure center.
As
they reported last week in Nature, Sanjiv Talwar and his colleagues did
just that, tickling the rats' brains via radio transmitter when the rodents
moved in a direction the researchers wanted. But although Talwar's team got the
rats to do things they ordinarily wouldn't--climb trees, go out in bright
light, ignore the scents of food and females--it took a controller at the helm
to make this happen.
So
although the rats may sound like cyborgs, they are really just rodents that
follow instructions. And although they fit into tiny spaces and are more or
less expendable, they are less useful in many ways than bloodhounds or
bomb-sniffing dogs--or even primitive robots, which will roll mindlessly into
fires, under water or into the glow of a nuclear-power-plant meltdown.
What's
truly novel about this project is the way the rat controllers issue their
instructions. By tapping a keyboard, they send signals via radio waves to
electrodes implanted in the animal's brain: a mild jolt to neurons that sense
the right whiskers means "turn right"; a zap to the left-whisker
neurons means "go left." The surprise was how easy this was to do.
Neurophysiologists have long dreamed of building artificial limbs with tactile
feedback that would be sufficiently sensitive to tell a user when a hand is
grasping a barbell tightly enough to keep it from falling or a baby chick
loosely enough to keep from crushing it.
That's
what Talwar and his group were trying to understand. "We wanted to determine
how well rats understand incoming signals," he explains. "When we
stimulated a region of the whiskers, they 'felt' a touch." Someday, says
Mandayam Srinivasan, director of the M.I.T. Touch Lab, who helped show two
years ago that monkeys could control robots by thought alone, "you could
build a neural chip for paralyzed people, similar to a cochlear implant for
deaf people, that uses brain signals to control prostheses.
Ethical
problems
"It
is a hard problem simply trying to make a robot move properly over
unpredictable terrain. It would be a simple matter to train rescue rats to
recognise and home in on the smell of a human trapped under rubble."
Dr
Talwar acknowledged there might be ethical objections to such ideas, even if
they could save human lives.
"Our
animals were completely happy and treated well and in no sense was there any
cruelty involved," he says.
"Nonetheless,
the idea is sort of creepy. I do not know what the answer is to that."
CONCLUSION
New
inventions in science always have ethics as a shadow.
So
what ever may be the ethics, the rat loves to become a RATBOT and helps to save
human life.
REFERENCES
No comments:
Post a Comment